@HuskerGarrett
Alright fine, here it is.
This was way back in the college days, me and a buddy meet up with some girl he's been talking to. We go out drinking, I'm third-wheeling it, on the prowl all night but end up striking out so we get hammered and stumble back to her place. We get there and continue drinking, at this point I've come to terms with sleeping on the couch while my friend gets some ass.
I'm sitting on the couch and her roommate walks through the door(solid 200lbs, 2/10 face, overall 1/10). She sits down, starts drinking with me, out of nowhere my friend's girl comes out of the bedroom and asks if I want to join them for a threesome. At this point, I'm so hammered I can barely see straight so of course, I agree.
Long story short, my friend wasn't up for it. I guess he was really into her so whatever. I decide to call it a night, I almost had a threesome with another dude for fucks sake.
Well here comes big Sheila and she's wanting some dick. In my head I'm thinking pussy's pussy, why not. None of the boys have to know about it. We go to her room, we try to foreplay a bit but her face was like kissing a basketball, I could barely get hard. It's pitch black, can't see shit. I start doing my thing, doggy style for about 5 min. I notice she's not moaning or anything so I think to myself, whatever she must just be a fish fuck.
By this time, my eyes are starting to adjust. I look down and my weiner is a straight limp noodle. I've been nailing her with my soft meat. Basically just fucking one of her rolls, maybe her ass crack idk.
I told her I had to puke, but instead of just going to puke I put all of my clothes on, she's asks if I'm going to puke why am I putting my clothes on? I don't even respond to her. I was so ashamed of myself that I walked 9 miles home at 4am. The way she goes...