I agree they need to consider the eye test argument when everything is equal, but Alabama's resume isn't better than FSU's this year. Every team has looked poorly one week or another. The FSU third string quarterback argument doesn't hold a ton of weight because their second string quarterback should be available for the bowl game anyway.
Alabama looked terrible last week against 6-6 Auburn that got pasted by New Mexico State the week before.
ESPN and the SEC swung their weight here, no question, and this whole year is tainted imo.