I said this in a different thread about Rivals new staff vs Tater Island (which is just the rehashed old RSS crew plus Sipple the Nipple) - Rivals/inside nebraska went and got some really good people. They write fair and balanced sutff, in a way that you can tell they actually know the game well. They give more pertinent info IMO, and in ways that are not a click-bait "I know (or knew) but couldn't tell you" way. I have been very impressed.
Not here to shit on anyone, but Tater Island has been subpar so far IMHO. Stale and just the same ole' ish that Rivals was before the big move on June 1st. I rarely visit Tater Island, no real reason to, but it was only a buck for the first year so I will give it that time frame. I don't see it really changing much though - it is what it is, and the new Rivals staff are heads and shoulders better writers than the crew that left and are now Tater Island.
Edit: I edited the first paragraph a little as after reading it again, it wasn't very clear - I was talking about Rivls vs Tater Island and how Rivals has a far better staff of writers now IMO.