Transfer QB

[realbp]

I’m shocked at the pushback you’re receiving. I think it seems reasonable.

I’m struggling to see how it’s a better use of money to get “cheaper” guys with zero success vice spending more on a guy who has had success. Neither scenario is guaranteed to work out. We’re acting like the money being spent is part of the government budget.

 

[Sous Chef]

I’m struggling to see how it’s a better use of money to get “cheaper” guys with zero success vice spending more on a guy who has had success. Neither scenario is guaranteed to work out. We’re acting like the money being spent is part of the government budget.

I'd be mad right along with you but after this season I've finally become almost entirely fatalistic and cynical. @Poor_and_Stupid has the only approach that allows me to stay sane. Couple our own propensity to punch ourselves in the nut sack with the direction college football as a whole is heading and my ability to give any fucks is almost zero.

 

[Irv]

I’m struggling to see how it’s a better use of money to get “cheaper” guys with zero success vice spending more on a guy who has had success. Neither scenario is guaranteed to work out. We’re acting like the money being spent is part of the government budget.

Maybe you could tell us the list of guys (not named Dylan) that you would be willing to guarantee the starting job to.

Then we will have to figure out if any of them are willing to gamble their future on playing in Dana’s offense of 2025, but at least that would give us a starting point.

Everyone keeps throwing out all of these definitions and labels of QBs they want or don’t want, but not a lot of actual names.

 

[realbp]

Maybe you could tell us the list of guys (not named Dylan) that you would be willing to guarantee the starting job to.

Then we will have to figure out if any of them are willing to gamble their future on playing in Dana’s offense of 2025, but at least that would give us a starting point.

Everyone keeps throwing out all of these definitions and labels of QBs they want or don’t want, but not a lot of actual names.

Sam Leavitt is the #1 guy for me

 

[Fitzjess21]

Maybe you could tell us the list of guys (not named Dylan) that you would be willing to guarantee the starting job to.

Then we will have to figure out if any of them are willing to gamble their future on playing in Dana’s offense of 2025, but at least that would give us a starting point.

Everyone keeps throwing out all of these definitions and labels of QBs they want or don’t want, but not a lot of actual names.

North Texas QB.

 

[Irv]

Sam Leavitt is the #1 guy for me

And we think he left Dillingham’s offense to improve his draft stock with ours? This is the problem.

 

[realbp]

And we think he left Dillingham’s offense to improve his draft stock with ours? This is the problem.

You are creating a narrative all on your own.

I’m under no illusions that just because I want them we’ll get them. You have to go after proven guys. If you don’t, you’re appointing TJ as QB1. They may very well have made that decision. I will have very little optimism going into next season if that’s the case.

 

[Blbmeb]

The way I see it is top QB’s go to top programs. I have no problem with swinging for the fences but in my mind I’m realistic about where we are as a program right now and what we will “probably “ get. My top two as of tonight are Minchey from Notre Dame and the kid from UNLV.

 

[NCsker]

Do you have an opinion on the subject matter? You seem to think that my take is the opposite of good. So, I assume you’re off the mind that we need to take two or possibly three career backups out guys who were competitive but lost the job in fall camp.

I’m probably somewhere in the middle. I’m certainly not sold on TJ and definitely think we need to bring in a proven commodity. I just think we need to be realistic about who we can get. I’d rather have someone who has had proven success at a lower school (ODU OR JMU qb for example) than some of those on here creaming about a P4 player like Kienholz or even Minchey that have upside but haven’t proven it yet.

I don’t necessarily disagree with you that we shouldn’t swing big, but as others have pointed out, I don’t think that Leavitt, Brown, or Sorsby are going to give us the time of day.

Then finally, yes I do think we need to figure out how to get a couple more bodies in the room next year of “walk on” type caliber. I’m just not sure what the approach to GET that level of athlete is, but I’m confused why that appears to be a point of contention.

 

[nscottie]

I’m probably somewhere in the middle. I’m certainly not sold on TJ and definitely think we need to bring in a proven commodity. I just think we need to be realistic about who we can get. I’d rather have someone who has had proven success at a lower school (ODU OR JMU qb for example) than some of those on here creaming about a P4 player like Kienholz or even Minchey that have upside but haven’t proven it yet.

I don’t necessarily disagree with you that we shouldn’t swing big, but as others have pointed out, I don’t think that Leavitt, Brown, or Sorsby are going to give us the time of day.

Then finally, yes I do think we need to figure out how to get a couple more bodies in the room next year of “walk on” type caliber. I’m just not sure what the approach to GET that level of athlete is, but I’m confused why that appears to be a point of contention.

This is where I’m at. Nothing wrong with swinging for the fences. But realistically the top guys aren’t coming here. We need too many other pieces.

 

[nscottie]

I’m probably somewhere in the middle. I’m certainly not sold on TJ and definitely think we need to bring in a proven commodity. I just think we need to be realistic about who we can get. I’d rather have someone who has had proven success at a lower school (ODU OR JMU qb for example) than some of those on here creaming about a P4 player like Kienholz or even Minchey that have upside but haven’t proven it yet.

I don’t necessarily disagree with you that we shouldn’t swing big, but as others have pointed out, I don’t think that Leavitt, Brown, or Sorsby are going to give us the time of day.

Then finally, yes I do think we need to figure out how to get a couple more bodies in the room next year of “walk on” type caliber. I’m just not sure what the approach to GET that level of athlete is, but I’m confused why that appears to be a point of contention.

This is where I’m at. Nothing wrong with swinging for the fences. But realistically the top guys aren’t coming here. We need too many other pieces.

 

[Irv]

You are creating a narrative all on your own.

I’m under no illusions that just because I want them we’ll get them. You have to go after proven guys. If you don’t, you’re appointing TJ as QB1. They may very well have made that decision. I will have very little optimism going into next season if that’s the case.

You’re not creating a narrative?

There’s all kinds of back channeling and tampering going on. Why would you assume we haven’t asked around about the top guys?

Just because you’re not hearing about it in rumors doesn’t mean nobody checked.

Maybe it would make you feel better if we leaked that we tried to get the best guys only to be told to pound sand. That might not be the best posture for the program though.

 

[Fitzjess21]

How much can we afford to throw at Conner Weigman from Houston?

 

[Hedley Lamarr]

How much can we afford to throw at Conner Weigman from Houston?

4 dollars and Runza for life (on Tuesdays)

 

[huskin1]

4 dollars and Runza for life (on Tuesdays)

Only during temp tuesdays not all year

 

[stonesak]

Weigman sounds like Peter Brady when he went through puberty.

 

[Cosmoc]

Former MSU QB Chiles Being Linked to Big Ten Team

There is a chance that Aidan Chiles will end up facing his former team next season. Rumors have been circulating that Nebraska is a team in the mix for Chiles'

www.si.com

 

[Toe]

I'd take him as a guy you're expecting to be a backup...