2025-26 #PortalSZN Thread

[Carm]

The scary thing to me is that I am guessing we get around 9 starters from our portal influx

 

[Kinish]

I'll say it.

Transfer portal rankings are fucking bogus. It's actually dumber than trying to rank a high school kid. All these rankings do is drive talking points for every schools Dean. They have more confirmation bias than a HS ranking and are a complete farce.

Oh this guy hasn't played at Alabama for 2 years, but going to Ohio State he's suddenly a top 20 prospect!

Give me a fucking break.

 

[Baron Winnebago]

I'll say it.

Transfer portal rankings are fucking bogus. It's actually dumber than trying to rank a high school kid. All these rankings do is drive talking points for every schools Dean. They have more confirmation bias than a HS ranking and are a complete farce.

Oh this guy hasn't played at Alabama for 2 years, but going to Ohio State he's suddenly a top 20 prospect!

Give me a fucking break.

"There's no evidence this guy is good at college football, but we rated him highly as a recruit and he has 3 years of eligibility left, so top 8?"

 

[vailhusker]

I'll say it.

Transfer portal rankings are fucking bogus. It's actually dumber than trying to rank a high school kid. All these rankings do is drive talking points for every schools Dean. They have more confirmation bias than a HS ranking and are a complete farce.

Oh this guy hasn't played at Alabama for 2 years, but going to Ohio State he's suddenly a top 20 prospect!

Give me a fucking break.

Last year James Williams was rated as a 4-Star transfer to FSU. If I remember right around the same rating as Princewill whose a 5-Star transfer this year by the way.

 

[Bootleg11]

I'll say it.

Transfer portal rankings are fucking bogus. It's actually dumber than trying to rank a high school kid. All these rankings do is drive talking points for every schools Dean. They have more confirmation bias than a HS ranking and are a complete farce.

Oh this guy hasn't played at Alabama for 2 years, but going to Ohio State he's suddenly a top 20 prospect!

Give me a fucking break.

There was a ton of proven production in the portal this year

 

[BigRedSob]

What was Indiana’s transfer portal ranking last year and the year before?

 

[Carm]

Last year James Williams was rated as a 4-Star transfer to FSU. If I remember right around the same rating as Princewill whose a 5-Star transfer this year by the way.

And not all lowly rated guys fail. Boerkircher was ranked 1835th in last year's On3 portal ratings with and 84.67 rating. A number of schools offered him more than we did, he selected A&M and played 481 snaps last season, and after a great senior bowl week he is being talked about as a guy who will get drafted,

The only guy we selected this year who wasn't rated with more ranking points than Nate had last year is the LS we took.

 

[Husker1]

I'll say it.

Transfer portal rankings are fucking bogus. It's actually dumber than trying to rank a high school kid. All these rankings do is drive talking points for every schools Dean. They have more confirmation bias than a HS ranking and are a complete farce.

Oh this guy hasn't played at Alabama for 2 years, but going to Ohio State he's suddenly a top 20 prospect!

Give me a fucking break.

I agree with this…unless our guys are ever rated highly. Like PFF, these ratings are dumb unless they are favorable to us. Then they’re great!

 

[Carm]

What was Indiana’s transfer portal ranking last year and the year before?

I'll give you 247s Indiana rankings (I don't like On3's because they net what came in against what went out. 247 simply scores the incoming class)

2026 8th
2025 25th
2024 30th

 

[Carm]

Kiffin is the 247 portal king

2026 1st
2025 4th
2024 1st

 

[BigRedSob]

I'll give you 247s Indiana rankings (I don't like On3's because they net what came in against what went out. 247 simply scores the incoming class)

2026 8th
2025 25th
2024 30th

Thank you, their 2024 ranking is similar to ours this year. Hopefully most of our guys are under the radar like indianas 2024 class

I mean we had the 13th ranked portal class last year, and it feels like most did not pan out.

 

[Carm]