I went over lockers a little last night and it seems like most consistent kickers that played their freshman year had a fairly consistent freshman season.Those 3 are also the only Freshmen in the top 80, and 2 of the 3 redshirted their first year.
Hardly any had a bad freshman season then turned it around to be a quality field goal kicker.
Sure there are outliers like Drew Brown, but doesn’t appear to be the norm