I selected Smothers because we have only one full game of him as the starting QB. Additionally, I really don’t know too much about the other QBs.
I thought AMart played a better game than Rattler head to head. Yes AMart did have the INT. But look what Rattler had protecting him compared to what AMart did. Considering OU had more talent and better lines of scrimmage; AMart was sacked 5 times, Rattler 0 times.
Lastly had we not shanked 2 FGs & 1 PAT attempt, the game outcome would’ve been different.
So I am not impressed with Rattler. Right now, Logan has a leg up on the current offense and may be better under the new OC. Logan may be more mobile than Rattler.