Better college QB: Vick vs RG3

[Jim14510]

Gimme RG3 personally

A

Agreed. Vick better in NFL though.

You two are bant for the rest of the week

 

[turek420845]

You two are bant for the rest of the week

I'm pansexual. You can't do that.

 

[Jim14510]

I'm pansexual. You can't do that.

Now you've got yourself 2 weeks

 

[turek420845]

Now you've got yourself 2 weeks

I'm taking this to the tPB Supreme Court.

 

[jw3]

without Vick, RG3 might have been playing WR.

 

[Pipe Line]

You two are bant for the rest of the week

Explanation: I’ve seen Vick’s college highlights. Ridiculous, no doubt. I really only saw RG3 his heisman season. My thing is, for both of them, when the game is on the line, who gives you more confidence? Overall, In college it’s RG3 for me, but in the NFL it’s Vick no doubt

 

[Jim14510]

Explanation: I’ve seen Vick’s college highlights. Ridiculous, no doubt. I really only saw RG3 his heisman season. My thing is, for both of them, when the game is on the line, who gives you more confidence? Overall, In college it’s RG3 for me, but in the NFL it’s Vick no doubt

In other words you never saw Vick play so you don't know. That should have been your original statement.

 

[Pipe Line]

In other words you never saw Vick play so you don't know. That should have been your original statement.

I watched I just don't remember a ton of him in college, bits and pieces. I remember more of his brother.

 

[Poor_and_Stupid]

Give me the dog fighter all the way

 

[Cash68847]

Explanation: I’ve seen Vick’s college highlights. Ridiculous, no doubt. I really only saw RG3 his heisman season. My thing is, for both of them, when the game is on the line, who gives you more confidence? Overall, In college it’s RG3 for me, but in the NFL it’s Vick no doubt

By the time RG3 was a senior he was a better all around qb than Vick was in college. RG3 would have had a good pro career, but he had one major problem. He is a toothpick and fragile.

 

[Eaton Beaver]

Maybe start a poll of R3 v D. Robinson

 

[Lionsfan93]

Just speaking of college, it's gotta be RG3. Both were remarkable, but RG3 was the better passer in college. Obviously Vick continued his greatness and carried on in the NFL way better. But college RG3 has gotta get the nod.