Better college QB: Vick vs RG3

[Goskers07]

Saw some highlights of both on my feed this morning. So who was better in college?

Vick: 2 year starter, 3,279 yards passing, 21 tds, 12 int, 1,216 rushing yards and 17 TDs. 1 national championship appearance. Finished 3rd in the Heisman race as a freshman. 21-1 as a starter.

RG3: 4 year starter (injured most of sophomore year), 10,366 yards passing, 78 tds, 17 int, 2,254 rushing yards, 33 tds. Heisman trophy winner. 23-18 as a starter.

 

[Pipe Line]

Gimme RG3 personally

 

[slattimer]

Vick. Freak show. The End.

 

[Tyneb23]

Vick played in a pro style offense and RG3 played in a wide open spreas offense. Vick was just different. RG3 played a few years in the NFL but when Vick should he could play pro style with the Falcons and more of a spread with Eagles. Easy choice Vick by a mile

 

[KidsSeeGhosts]

Vick would've been insane in a modern college football offense. RG3 has the production tho.

 

[iruletheskool]

Vick by a lot

 

[Eaton Beaver]

RGlll lead Baylor to lots of wins and I'm not sure they won a game before him but Vick was still better

 

[doublewing]

Not even a contest for me. Vick by a mile.

There hasn't been a player approaching his unique athleticism at the QB position, CFB or NFL. Better ones for sure, but Vick was a freak.

 

[BingoDingo]

Vick. It's definitely Vick.

 

[Jim14510]

Vick. Freak show. The End.

This.

That VA Tech team without Vick would have been bad. With him they go to the national championship game.

Baylor without RG3 would have been OK. They were pretty good with.

 

[Cash68847]

Saw some highlights of both on my feed this morning. So who was better in college?

Vick: 2 year starter, 3,279 yards passing, 21 tds, 12 int, 1,216 rushing yards and 17 TDs. 1 national championship appearance. Finished 3rd in the Heisman race as a freshman. 21-1 as a starter.

RG3: 4 year starter (injured most of sophomore year), 10,366 yards passing, 78 tds, 17 int, 2,254 rushing yards, 33 tds. Heisman trophy winner. 23-18 as a starter.

Vick was the most electric. The guy who reminded me of him in college was Lamar Jackson.

 

[ChocaEgg]

Vick was the most electric. The guy who reminded me of him in college was Lamar Jackson.

I'd have Lamar ahead of rg3 too

 

[Cash68847]

I'd have Lamar ahead of rg3 too

If I had to pick a qb for one year to carry a team in college my vote goes to Cam Newton. He was a man among boys in college.

 

[slattimer]

If I had to pick a qb for one year to carry a team in college my vote goes to Cam Newton. He was a man among boys in college.

He had the perfect HC/OC for his skill set. You couldn't have asked for a better fit than what Mahlzan does for Newton. Power Read stuff with Cam as the downhill portion, shear hell to plan for IMO.

 

[Bootleg11]

This isn’t really a debate. Vick all the way

 

[Bootleg11]

If I had to pick a qb for one year to carry a team in college my vote goes to Cam Newton. He was a man among boys in college.

No doubt

 

[Cash68847]

He had the perfect HC/OC for his skill set. You couldn't have asked for a better fit than what Mahlzan does for Newton. Power Read stuff with Cam as the downhill portion, shear hell to plan for IMO.

It’s a good thing Auburn gave daddy Newton a better deal because Cam was going to go to Mississippi State. He would have been a pretty good fit there too. It worked out in the end for all parties. It’s also funny to think Cam was Tebow’s backup at Florida. Urb was pulling in major talent.

 

[iruletheskool]

Choice also obvious based on NFL career

 

[turek420845]

A

Gimme RG3 personally

Agreed. Vick better in NFL though.

 

[Pipe Line]

A

Agreed. Vick better in NFL though.

100%