Liquid aeration
Break up compacted soil with N-Ext Air-8™ Liquid Aeration. Improve water penetration, encourage deeper rooting, and boost oxygen levels with an easy-to-apply formula containing 8% humic acid. Covers up to 21,300 sq ft per gallon. A hassle-free alternative to mechanical aeration.
yardmastery.com
Or a starter fert with liquid aeration... I used this and was very impressed with the color.
N-Ext 16-21-2 GreenePOP™ is a liquid starter fertilizer. If you are seeding or sodding your lawn, this is your foundation product. It's also great for existing lawns if you need a good dose of phosphorus to correct a deficiency. Also includes liquid aeration in the mix. One gallon covers up to...
yardmastery.com
Mechanical aeration is better when you get the area done at a high level. A liquid will get 100% of the soil aerated vs just where the plugs are. Also I don't have to dick around with the machine.
Another pro to the liquid is you don't have to worry about hitting a sprinkler head and ruining the sprinkler head.
Don't do a mechanical aeration in the spring. Your preemergent basically makes a barrier so weeds don't come up. You mechanically aerate it you basically break that barrier and ruin your preemergent.