I don't think it was a 'show' offer because we didn't think he'd take it. It was high so we'd have a chance
Edwards is fine, but he also played at a lower level (UConn) and only has one year left, not 3. Edwards' games with over 100 yards rushing were Delaware, Air Force, Central CT, Ball St, Florida Atlantic, and Army. Not exactly B1G level competition. Barthel was actually his position coach at UConn in 2022, so one would expect he is familiar with the guy.
These are my favorite types of straw man arguments because it conveniently ignores things like the last time Michigan State took a running back from UConn in Nate Carter he ran for 1300 yards in his 2 years at MSU on dogshit teams and now is on the Atlanta Falcons. Edwards is very good. He’s going to be good for Mich State.Makhi Hughes seemed like a great get by Oregon after 2 huge years at Tulane, but he barely played at Oregon. He is similar in that if you go back and look at his stats from Tulane, he had 1 - 100+ yard game against P4 competition in 5 chances over 2 years.
Keelan Marion for Miami started at UConn, EJ was our best RB last year, finished as an All American and barely even had other FBS offers when we took him. Mizzou took a D2 RB and made him all SEC. Pretty sure the stats bare out the most effective transfers into P4 programs come from G5s or FCS as overlooked guys from HS or bounce backs from earlier in their careers