Agree they’re fine but the committee logic shit. Also if it comes down to it Miami should get in over ND but they clearly aren’t doing that.
-
Welcome to The Platinum Board! We are a Nebraska Cornhuskers news source and community. Please click "Log In" or "Register" above to gain access to the forums.
Breaking College Football Playoff Selection
- Thread starter Kaladin
- Start date
If Texas was 10-2 and they played central Mich instead of #1osu would they be in the playoff … yes or no?
No, thought I was clear about that earlier haha
They def would be, have 3 of the best 5 wins in the country.
I mean 2
So uga shouldn’t be in the playoff if they lose to bama, correct ?
Correct - they would easily be in the playoff. Best resume of 2 loss teams
Ah I get it now. I was thinking 12 team, both are ranked in the top 12, but I forgot about the auto G5 winner, so it's basically top 11. Yeah, I'm indifferent on Miami or ND. I could be sold on both as being basically a last in. However, I don't think Miami should get in in general, given they've looked very overrated all year, and contextually speaking ND hasn't looked great either when it matters, and their lack of conference should be a negative in that same conversation.
If CPC had clear protocol for that maybe. They have a bad loss to Dawgs and FU. OT with bad KY.
I don't believe it, but my point is the fucking whining. It's terrible. Fans one thing, but Sark, admin, and political figures in TX. Gross. Looks bad whenever that happens, but this shit on steroids. So, I don't care if in or not without tOSU. I just want entitled TX to go back to B12. BTW, thought the same about Bama, SC, Miss whining last year. Not the fans, but the schools and coaches and Greg Sankey. Bad look. If their takeaway is schedule sister's of the poor then so be it. Sucks for their fans watching quality games. Also, SEC going to 9 con schedule next year. So, that matchup gonna happen anyway even if they cancel the tOSU game. When we had 4 team playoffs losing a big non con game I don't remember this much crying. It's gotten worse with expansion, and TX has turned to 11.
lol I notice you’re not dinging uga for their squeaker against FL. Also - are you capable of using paragraphs ?
I don't even know what you're arguing at this point lol. UGA went through this after undefeated regular season in 23. TX doesn't need your support with the crying. They got all their bases covered. And, if UGA loses in SECCG and they kept them out all the crying in the world won't change anything.
Says the guy that keeps crying about ‘23. Someone get this guy a calendar.
This seems pretty personal to you. I don't agree with ya though, but I'm ok with you having your opinion.
Texas is arguing that we are going to see good noncon games go away. But what they are actually asking is that the game be made into an exhibition where nobody risks anything. It’ll be like an early season bowl.
If the game has no potential negative consequences, it’s meaningless.
The reality is that I’m less concerned about teams getting punished for losing a tough noncon game than I am about teams not being rewarded for winning them (Miami).
lol not personal, just logic. Just a fact Texas would be in the playoff if they played a crap team instead of Osu.
Same reason I’m advocating Nebraska cancels any and all tough non-conf opponent. Just play three easy teams at home. Playing a tough non-conf opponent has little upside and a lot of downside. Why you’re arguing this is quite baffling
Don't you think H2H should matter as Miami beat ND this year.
Yes, but that doesn't change my opinion that I don't think either should be in it this year.
ND has no business being in the playoff. Go back to 4 teams.
Go back to the BCS. Winner of B1G vs SEC most years would be cinema.
Similar threads
