NFL 23/24 season thread

[jickey moseph]

QB 1
66.7% completion %
254 yds per game
7.55 yds per attempt
1.67 TDs per game
.67 picks per game
97.3 RTG
.049 fumbles lost per game
.25 rushing TDs per game
66% Winning %
No Conference Championships


QB 2
63.2% Completion %
241 yds per game
7.22 yds per attempt
1.81 TDs per game
.79 picks per game
93.1 RTG
.15 fumbles lost per game
.5 rushing TDs per game
67% winning %
No Conference Championships

They are the exact same QB

Spoiler: Click me

Dak QB1 Allen QB2

Spoken like a Chiefs’ fan and avid Bills hater. I’d take Allen over Dak every day that ends in -y. I also feel like Dak has had a much more complimentary running game w Zeke, etc… than Allen has ever had.

Allen has had a really good start to the season… he’s what, ~73% completion rate so far? He got banged around tonight and I think his shoulder got a little tweaked early in the game. The game winning TD throw was special.

 

[jickey moseph]

@Faux Sean Callahan stats are stats though so I don’t know what I’m arguing about tbh I’m an idiot.

Good find with those.

I’m a Pack fan so I have no room to talk. We’re in purgatory so far this season.

 

[Jim14510]

Minus Allen's turnover rate

Mahomes is like .15 less per game. So 1 less every 6 games.

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

Spoken like a Chiefs’ fan and avid Bills hater. I’d take Allen over Dak every day that ends in -y. I also feel like Dak has had a much more complimentary running game w Zeke, etc… than Allen has ever had.

Allen has had a really good start to the season… he’s what, ~73% completion rate so far? He got banged around tonight and I think his shoulder got a little tweaked early in the game. The game winning TD throw was special.

@Faux Sean Callahan stats are stats though so I don’t know what I’m arguing about tbh I’m an idiot.

Good find with those.

I’m a Pack fan so I have no room to talk. We’re in purgatory so far this season.

I think if you were to build a QB in a lab, it would look very close to what Josh Allen is.

Problem is with taking care of the ball.

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

Mahomes is like .15 less per game. So 1 less ever 6 games.

Allen fumbles a lot
Mahomes
.65 Turnovers per Game

Allen
.94 Turnovers per game


Mahomes
66.5 Completion %
300.4 yds passing per game
8 Yds per attempt
2.4 TDs per game
105 RTG
80.2 winning %
58.3 winning % when trailing by 10 points or more during the game. This is 9 bsp from Allen and Dak's total record.
2× Super Bowl champion (LIV, LVII)
2× Super Bowl MVP (LIV, LVII)
2× NFL Most Valuable Player (2018, 2022)
3x Conference Champion (2019, 2020 & 2022)

 

[Jim14510]

Allen fumbles a lot
Mahomes
.65 Turnovers per Game

Allen
.94 Turnovers per game

.3 turnovers per game!!!!

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

.3 turnovers per game!!!!

I prefer 45% more turnovers per game.

Positioning Jimbo

 

[Jim14510]

I prefer 45% more turnovers per game.

Positioning Jimbo

I didn't say I preferred it. 1 turnover every 3 games is not a big deal though.

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

I didn't say I preferred it. 1 turnover every 3 games is not a big deal though.

Except Allen is averaging a turnover a game... 1 extra every 3.

It really isn't fair comparing him to a QB as great as Mahomes though..

 

[Jim14510]

Except Allen is averaging a turnover a game

Just stahp

 

[Jim14510]

Except Allen is averaging a turnover a game... 1 extra every 3.

It really isn't fair comparing him to a QB as great as Mahomes though..

Allen also has 3200 rushing yards compared to Mahomes 1800. Would expect him to fumble more with 1 1/2 times the carries.

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

Allen also has 3200 rushing yards compared to Mahomes 1800. Would expect him to fumble more with 1 1/2 times the carries.

Using that logic makes Allen's interceptions look worse... Mahomes throws for 60 yards more per game, but yet takes care of the ball at a higher level while passing.

Josh Allen has 600% more fumbles than Mahomes.

Allen is just awful at taking care of the ball to this point in his career...

 

[Jim14510]

Allen is just awful at taking care of the ball to this point in his career...

Your post is fine until here. I get that you're going over the top on purpose but if Allen is just awful for having 1 more turnover per 3 games then Mahomes is just bad.

 

[Jim14510]

You can't have Mahomes doesn't turn it over too much and Allen is awful. You're going to have to pick one or the other.

 

[Jim14510]

.73
.75
1.05
1.12
1.29

5 of the best QB's of all time.

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

.73
.75
1.05
1.12
1.29

5 of the best QB's of all time.

I swear if one of those is Eli Manning I’m going to get @HuskerGarrett to ban you

 

[SlumpBuster]

.73
.75
1.05
1.12
1.29

5 of the best QB's of all time.

Hmm...Tom Brady was .63, Joe Montana was .72, Marino was 1.04, Manning .94

No idea who the 5 were. 1 has to be "most overrated ever" Terry Bradshaw 😉 who clocked in at 1.25

 

[Jim14510]

Hmm...Tom Brady was .63, Joe Montana was .72, Marino was 1.04, Manning .94

No idea who the 5 were. 1 has to be "most overrated ever" Terry Bradshaw 😉 who clocked in at 1.25

Fumbles are always different depending what site you use.

Brady
Montana
Peyton Manning
Marino
Favre (being generous with one of the best but knew he'd be high)

 

[Faux Sean Callahan]

 

[Jim14510]

Looking for a new contract. Wishing he would have thought of ownership before Caleb.