Welcome to The Platinum Board

We are a Nebraska Husker fan community. Please either login or register for an account

  • Welcome to The Platinum Board! We are a Nebraska Cornhuskers news source and community. Please click "Log In" or "Register" above to gain access to the forums.

Editorial Why players who have once been on scholarship can't go on NIL-only arrangements

Carm

Graduate Assistant
Recruiting Analyst
Insider
Elite Member
tPB OG
Messages
7,045
Likes
31,324
Location
Novi, Michigan
Every school, as we all know, gets to have 85 scholarship players on the roster every season

In the P5, when a player gets a scholarship, the length of the commitment is tied to eligibility, not graduation. The scholarship commitment lasts 5 years or until eligibility is exhausted if that comes first.

To be one of the 85 (a “counter”), a player needs to be recruited. This generally means the player has taken an official visit, received an official financial aid offer after the August 1st following junior year, or has signed a National Letter of Intent. The player also must receive athletically related financial aid in year in which the player has remaining eligibility to be a counter.

Aid which is not athletically related includes scholarships available to anyone, family funding, and the player’s outside employment income. There is, however, an especially important exception to outside employment income:


1701702964485.png

We have a number of players who played in 2020 and are entering year six of eligibility (because the 2020 Covid year doesn’t count as a use of one of the maximum 5 eligibility years each student starts with). Could those players play year 6 at Nebraska without using a scholarship and get NIL and not count against the 85? The answer is No because of the exception above – they would not be on scholarship, but they would still be receiving athletic aid and still be a counter. Therefore, there is no reason not to give them a scholarship if they stay.

This same rule would appear to apply to recruited transfers out of the portal.

This same framework explains why PWOs do not get official visits – it would make them recruited. Anyone who took an official visit would be a counter even if they came to Nebraska and simply received NIL.

This explains the number we have for recruits and transfers. When 6th year guys stay – which is a good thing – they use a scholarship spot which could go to a transfer or HS recruit. As the guys who played in 2020 leave the player pool, this problem will go away because all players will be on scholarship until they are at school 5 years or use their 4 years of eligibility.

We will be able to get to 85 for 2024 with certainty even though we are way over 85 currently. This is because Rhule can still cut players under the new HC Rhule until fall practice starts next August. The pool of players he can cut excludes any recruits or transfers signed players he signed an any transfers. This pool, however, is only roughly a third of the total scholarship players including the committed class of 2024.
 
Every school, as we all know, gets to have 85 scholarship players on the roster every season

In the P5, when a player gets a scholarship, the length of the commitment is tied to eligibility, not graduation. The scholarship commitment lasts 5 years or until eligibility is exhausted if that comes first.

To be one of the 85 (a “counter”), a player needs to be recruited. This generally means the player has taken an official visit, received an official financial aid offer after the August 1st following junior year, or has signed a National Letter of Intent. The player also must receive athletically related financial aid in year in which the player has remaining eligibility to be a counter.

Aid which is not athletically related includes scholarships available to anyone, family funding, and the player’s outside employment income. There is, however, an especially important exception to outside employment income:


View attachment 30559

We have a number of players who played in 2020 and are entering year six of eligibility (because the 2020 Covid year doesn’t count as a use of one of the maximum 5 eligibility years each student starts with). Could those players play year 6 at Nebraska without using a scholarship and get NIL and not count against the 85? The answer is No because of the exception above – they would not be on scholarship, but they would still be receiving athletic aid and still be a counter. Therefore, there is no reason not to give them a scholarship if they stay.

This same rule would appear to apply to recruited transfers out of the portal.

This same framework explains why PWOs do not get official visits – it would make them recruited. Anyone who took an official visit would be a counter even if they came to Nebraska and simply received NIL.

This explains the number we have for recruits and transfers. When 6th year guys stay – which is a good thing – they use a scholarship spot which could go to a transfer or HS recruit. As the guys who played in 2020 leave the player pool, this problem will go away because all players will be on scholarship until they are at school 5 years or use their 4 years of eligibility.

We will be able to get to 85 for 2024 with certainty even though we are way over 85 currently. This is because Rhule can still cut players under the new HC Rhule until fall practice starts next August. The pool of players he can cut excludes any recruits or transfers signed players he signed an any transfers. This pool, however, is only roughly a third of the total scholarship players including the committed class of 2024.
Thanks for breaking that down for us, Carm. As always, I appreciate your contributions to the board.
 
What about Borkircher and Bullock? Can they go back to walk on status?
 
So when we took walk ons and made a big show of putting them on scholarship (when we could have given them the same money in NIL) we were essentially fucking ourselves RE: future available scholarships...is this correct?
 
So when we took walk ons and made a big show of putting them on scholarship (when we could have given them the same money in NIL) we were essentially fucking ourselves RE: future available scholarships...is this correct?
I thought those scholarships were always 1-year arrangements
 
What about Borkircher and Bullock? Can they go back to walk on status?
Presumably yes - I am sure Bullock can. It depends on whether they were "recruited" initially. "Recruited", as I suggest above, does not have the everyday meaning. It is defined so that specific things need to occur.
 
So when we took walk ons and made a big show of putting them on scholarship (when we could have given them the same money in NIL) we were essentially fucking ourselves RE: future available scholarships...is this correct?
No - it is being "recruited" prior to enrollment that is the trigger. If they were not initially recruited, they can return to walk-on status. This scholarships are not guaranteed for 5 years.
 
I asked in another thread but am going to ask here. Could a portal guy "walk on" with simply NIL if we don't "recruit" him? He doesn't take an official visit etc?
 
I asked in another thread but am going to ask here. Could a portal guy "walk on" with simply NIL if we don't "recruit" him? He doesn't take an official visit etc?
I answered it in that thread, but the answer is Yes, if they are not recruited AND aren't bringing with them a prior school's obligation for a 5 year eligibility athletic aid package. Those obligations carry over to the transferee school.
 

Theme customization system

You can customize some areas of the forum theme from this menu.

  • Wide/Narrow view

    You can control a structure that you can use to use your theme wide or narrow.

    Grid view forum list

    You can control the layout of the forum list in a grid or ordinary listing style structure.

    Close sidebar

    You can get rid of the crowded view in the forum by closing the sidebar.

    Fixed sidebar

    You can make it more useful and easier to access by pinning the sidebar.

  • Color combinations cannot be used

    Color combinations are not available to you, this area may be restricted by administrators. Please contact the administrator for more information.

    Color gradient backgrounds
Back